County Urges Barrier Island Cities to Ban Large Beach-Digging Tools to Protect Public and Wildlife
Deep holes on Manatee County beaches continue to pose hazards to both people and wildlife, prompting county officials to call for an islandwide approach to regulating beach-digging tools.
Charlie Hunsicker, Director of the Manatee County Natural Resources Department, addressed the Coalition of Barrier Island Elected Officials (CBIEO) on May 20, asking member municipalities to consider ordinances that align with the county’s current regulations. The CBIEO includes leaders from Anna Maria, Bradenton Beach, Holmes Beach, and Longboat Key.
The county already prohibits metal shovels and beach holes deeper than one foot at its managed beaches, including Manatee Public Beach, Coquina Beach, Cortez Beach, and Bayfront Park. However, these rules do not extend to the rest of the island, where individual city codes govern public behavior.
Hunsicker explained that the proliferation of large holes—often dug by beachgoers—has become a “continuous problem,” creating safety risks for both people and nesting sea turtles. The holes can be difficult to see, especially at night, and can trap or injure wildlife.
Mark Taylor, the county’s beach rake operator, described the growing issue from a maintenance standpoint. He reported encountering holes deep enough to trap his tractor and expressed concern for lifeguards and emergency responders who risk injury from unmarked holes as they drive across the sand.
Taylor emphasized the need for a unified approach across the barrier islands, suggesting that consistent rules would help address safety and environmental concerns more effectively.
In response, Holmes Beach Mayor Judy Titsworth confirmed she has directed her city staff to draft an ordinance reflecting the county’s. Bradenton Beach Mayor John Chappie and Anna Maria Mayor Mark Short indicated they would also consider such legislation, although they acknowledged enforcement could be a challenge.
Despite these concerns, Hunsicker urged that simply having a regulation in place could serve as a deterrent and help reduce the number of dangerous beach holes.
The proposal is expected to be discussed further at upcoming city commission meetings, with the potential for islandwide coordination to improve beach safety and wildlife protection.
