A dispute between Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier and Saint Stephen’s Episcopal School in Bradenton has drawn statewide attention, with conflicting accounts emerging over the removal of students, objections to classroom reading materials, and the school’s handling of tuition payments.
Uthmeier has raised concerns that the private school may have violated Florida consumer protection laws by removing students after their parents complained about reading assignments they considered sexually explicit. However, Saint Stephen’s Head of School Peter Kraft disputes those allegations, maintaining that the families were separated from the school because of repeated violations of its conduct policies rather than their objections to instructional materials.
In a five-page letter dated November 12, 2026, Uthmeier outlined potential violations of the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act, which prohibits unfair or deceptive business practices. The attorney general contends that the school made representations about its educational environment and curriculum that were inconsistent with materials assigned to students.
The letter identifies four literary works that prompted concerns: The Poet X by Elizabeth Acevedo, Girl and Annie John by Jamaica Kincaid, and Answers in the Pages by David Levithan. Uthmeier argues that portions of these works contain sexual content or address subjects that conflict with assurances allegedly provided to parents during enrollment.
The attorney general also questioned the school’s application of its Standard of Civility policy, which allows administrators to terminate a family’s enrollment under certain circumstances. According to Uthmeier, the policy could permit the school to dismiss students because their parents disagree with instructional practices while retaining tuition payments.
Kraft presented a different account in an email distributed Tuesday to the Saint Stephen’s school community and subsequently reported by The Bradenton Journal.
According to Kraft, the families involved were not removed simply for questioning classroom materials. He maintained that their separation followed repeated and serious violations of the school’s civility standards, including threats of litigation, attempts to damage the school’s reputation, and confrontational interactions with faculty and administrators.
Kraft said school officials made multiple attempts to meet with the families and address their concerns before the decisions were made. He also alleged that some parents disrupted a school event, contacted educational and governing organizations regarding the school’s accreditation, and publicly challenged the professionalism of teachers.
The head of school maintained that the decisions were made in consultation with the school’s Board of Trustees and were based on conduct rather than disagreement over educational content.
The curriculum itself remains another point of disagreement.
Kraft challenged the attorney general’s characterization of the reading assignments, stating that two of the books referenced in coverage of the controversy were not included in the school’s 2026–2027 curriculum. He also said a third work had been misrepresented and was assigned to Upper School students rather than Middle School students.
Kraft did not identify which specific titles he was referencing in his explanation.
He further maintained that materials assigned to Middle School students did not contain sexually explicit content or serve an ideological purpose. According to Kraft, Saint Stephen’s has an established process allowing families to request alternative reading assignments when they object to particular books.
The financial consequences of the families’ separation are also disputed.
Uthmeier’s letter raises concerns about provisions in the school’s enrollment contract that could require families to pay an entire year’s tuition even if their children no longer attend. The attorney general also questioned contractual language allowing the school to withhold academic records when tuition balances remain unpaid.
Kraft responded that Saint Stephen’s followed its established financial policies, discontinued monthly tuition payments after the families were separated, refunded applicable credits, and provided official transcripts and supporting records to the families and their new schools.
His explanation did not specify the amounts refunded or clarify whether any additional tuition obligations remained outstanding.
In his November 12 letter, Uthmeier directed the school to preserve records related to the dispute, cease efforts to collect tuition from the affected families or withhold their academic records, and address potential financial harm. He requested a complete response by November 30, 2026.
The attorney general’s office has indicated that violations of the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act could result in legal remedies, including restitution, damages, and civil penalties of up to $10,000 per violation.
However, the allegations outlined in the letter do not constitute a legal finding that Saint Stephen’s violated state law, and no lawsuit has been announced in the information available.
The controversy has also prompted differing reactions within the school community.
Saint Stephen’s senior Marcus Motwani, who has attended the school since third grade, expressed support for the institution and described his educational experience positively. Motwani credited the school with helping him develop leadership skills and said he had not personally considered the classroom materials he encountered to be explicit.
In its initial response to the attorney general’s inquiry, Saint Stephen’s stated that it would cooperate with the investigation and provide the requested documentation. School officials maintained that the institution had acted ethically and in accordance with its educational values, policies, and Florida law.
Kraft has reiterated the school’s intention to work through the appropriate channels while continuing its academic and educational mission.
The dispute highlights competing interpretations of parental rights, private school authority, curriculum decisions, and contractual obligations. While private schools generally have discretion in establishing educational programs and conduct expectations, the attorney general maintains that they remain subject to applicable consumer protection laws.
At the center of the disagreement is whether the families were separated because they raised legitimate concerns about classroom materials or because their subsequent conduct violated established school policies.
Those competing accounts have not been independently resolved.
Saint Stephen’s is expected to provide its formal response to the attorney general’s office by November 30. The outcome of that review could determine whether the state pursues additional action.
For now, both the attorney general’s office and school leadership maintain substantially different positions regarding the circumstances surrounding the families’ departure, the instructional materials involved, and the school’s financial obligations.
